Lots lists and discussions about our favourite G albums . Mine is ATOTT ( although if forced to choose I'd have to go for SO) but those albums are not my most played. Also I certainly veer towards the mid/ early Genesis as my favourite era however I noticed that I tend to play their later albums more often, with Genesis (shapes) being played most frequently which for me ranks quite low in my list of favourites. This factoid only occurred to me when playing Shapes recently. I rarely have any Genesis album on as background listening. Although I don't keep an account of what and when I play here is my rough guess as to my most played albums with with the position of my ranking in brackets. As said this is a rough guess and have only just thought about it . Clearly I need to give some live albums more attention!
1 .Genesis (11)
2. Duke (9)
3.Abacab (15)
4.CAS (18)
5.WCD (14)
6.IT (13)
7.SEBTP (5)
8.ATTWT (7)
9.ATOTT(2)
1O. Foxtrot (6)
11.W & W (3)
12 SO (1)
13.NC (8)
14.TLLDOB (4)
15. Trespass (12)
16 GL (10)
17.WIR(16)
18.TSL (17)
19.TWWW (19) ( rare play , I've watched the DVD more often)
20. FGTR (20) ( I hardly play this from one year to the next)
As a guess it has to be something like this.
My rankings do change but not by great deal.