Sorry to hear you guys don't like Nad Sylvan's persona or vocal style. I've grown to appreciate the man and his many talents. Have any of you heard his Unifaun album where he and one other artist, Bonamici, play every instrument? It's a tribute to all eras of Genesis via Nad's own compositions. Fabulous stuff. He was recruited by Roine Stolt of Flower Kings fame to be the vocalist in Agents Of Mercy. They released a few good albums. Nad's two solo albums are very good as well. I met Nad at an Agents Of Mercy gig. He was staying at the same hotel my wife and I were staying at. We talked over breakfast the day after the gig. The man is very timid, but very intelligent as well. He loves Genesis' music as much as we do, even more since he has dedicated a big chunk of his life to re-creating it with none other than Steve Hackett himself. I don't believe Steve would have chosen Nad out of who knows how many potential Gabriel/Collins sound-alikes to go on tour with him if he didn't think he was up to the task. Even Collins and Gabriel found it difficult to sing live without straining their voices each night. Regarding the Wind And Wuthering album - I'm not sure of you guys' ages, but for those of us who bought the album when it first came out, it was a special time in our lives and a special album. Anyway, that's my bit of a rant. Carry on...