Posts by Nanunami

Without a doubt - 15 points. It's actually nice to revisit the old band version, it has a certain different feel and an amazing power. I would love to hear that version today with a full band. Nevertheless, his piano version is also amazing - and also worth 15 points.

Sad to hear he quits the band. I wasn't convinced in the beginning and also had my doubts when Steve started his Genesis Revisited tour - but Gary did a fabulous job. Hope there's an interesting replacement. Can't think of a specific name, they are make more or less sense, but also there are plenty of things which makes certain people unlikely. So either Steve will surprie us all or it will be someone we simply don't know yet.

I have quit Facebook a while ago. Used to be a member of the movement and access all eras as well, and in addition some others I can't really remember. I have no idea why people ran away from forums to be part of facebook groups. It's posted and forgotten, there is no archive to check etc.

Selling England is among my favorite albums by the band. Nevertheless, there are time when I don't listen to it at all. Sometimes it feels a bit "old", then again some ideas and tracks don't match with the standard of the others. I always thought that The Battle Of Epping Forest was awful, but I learned to accept this one as well (thanks to The Musical Box).

Firth Of Fifth and The Cinema Show are one of two top 5 all time Genesis classics.

14 Points for me. One of my all time favorites. There are not many tracks by the band that I consider to be better, so 14 points seem to be appropriate.

Not a song title, but Vampire Weekend have a track called Cape Cod Kwassa Kwassa and one of the lines is "it feels so unnatural, Peter Gabriel too"

Peter in fact did record that track as well and he added the line "it feels so unnatural to sing your own name"

indeed he did

Quite a nice version!

Nevertheless I prefer Ray playing his own stuff (apart from the CAS tracks and maybe Carpet Crawlers)

I believe Steve said that the London show was filmed for a possible concert film release.

Got my copy. It's a great artbook with liner notes etc.

But I also think they missed a chance here. There ist no 5.1 mix of an entire album (Wild Orchids would have benefited a lot I am sure) and I believe there are several rare and unreleased tracks /versions worth another full CD (or two?). This set is more for people who don't have these albums, rather than for die hard fans.

I always loved Collins as a drummer. It's hard to seem him that was. On the other hand, it was harder to see the first videos from 2017, when he didn' do anything at all apart from singing and sitting down.

It's nice to see him doing some little rhythm thing, but obviously hopes for more won't be fulfilled.

Well, it's okay, but more than 9 points do not seem appropriate. It's a track for radio, decently produced and that's it. There are better tracks on that album.

This is one of my favorite Collins tracks, maybe one out of five worth 15 points.

I remember he played in live in 1997 solo on the e-piano. Absolutely amazing tune. The studio version also features Sting on backing vocals.

This is great news! I'm curious how mich from Spectral Mornings he will play in the end, but I am definitely going!

I've seen the band three times and can highly recommend their shows. They are also nice guys - simply fans like us!

I bought it straight away when it came out. I noticed the passion and hard work everybody involved has put into this project. It's a nice app!

Interesting: Kim Poor is not mentioned in this App like she was in the original book ....

Nearly Outstanding. And in comparison to other tracks of the band it's quite unique. It's a shame they didn't do that live in later years, 2007 for example. Maybe it would have worked with Ray Wilson in 1998?

14 Points

I also enjoyed watching this. I was actually hoping for more footage of the NYC rehearsals in 2006, since they tried a couple of odd tracks there.

But all in all a great one, many things really made me laugh.

In any case: the original CD/DVD or SACD/DVD sets are out of print. So it would be only logical to make them available again.

Quote from Noni

This album still remains in my top 6 of Genesis music

really? Please explain ...

Great to have you here as well!

I remember the first things you've done many years ago. Curious what will come