Posts by WILL_son

Oh that is a nice track. 12 from me.

I like Havens‘ voice as well (also on „Make tomorrow“ by Peter Gabriel)

This is a video of "Amelia", currently my top track on his latest album "Weight of man". It has a little mystical / proggy flavour...

My favorites have not changed a lot, but right now "And Still" is my favorite, "Live And Let Live" and "Road To Joy" close behind.

"Panopticom" has become my least favorite track, but that sounds like it's not good, and that isn wrong. It is a strong album in general.

I would say 12 points. There's something missing for me to give more points, not even sure why / what. Still, this is a good track!

13 !!

Love it. Simple, straight to the point and catchy.

Here's a live recording from Ray

ok, let's carry on ...

Ray did a lot of cover versions over the years, and the majority of them live. On his recent album, there's a cover of the Beatles track "Golden Slumbers" and on "Song For A Friend", there's a cover of the Pink Floyd classic "High Hopes". This track also has a music video (which was produced in 2021).

A great pop song! 13 from me.

That's a fine track and it should have been on the album!

13!

Take-away-message: There will be boxsets in the future...

Great groove, great hook, great song. That’s a 12/15 for me …

Quote from Henry Hamilton-Smythe

To me, it doesn't matter if any of the Genesis members are involved. I'm just hoping that the end result will allow us to hear the album the way the band intended. And, that we can actually hear the individual instruments.

Just not sure how the band's involvement would ultimately make any difference.

I think it mattters a lot whether or not the original musicians are involved in such a project. Right now we don’t really know what the essence of this is, but should they really remix / reproduce the album, then their involvement is crucial …

“Gouranga” was always a strange one for me …

It was a b-side but also a bonus track on “Change”.

Today I like it more than when it came out.

What do you think?

oh oh oh

one of my favorite Wilson songs. Simple, melodic - a very good track.

"A Different Drum" is my key track on this (for me rather complicated) album.

"Zaar" is also nice. Third track was tough to pick. I have chosen "It Is Accomplished".

I must say I have my problems with those soundtrack / instrumental albums, same with Steve. But I know "Passion" is an important album in Peter's catalogue.

20 years?????

"If I Were You" stands out. I was surprised they played this in 2011 (?)

I also like "Falling" and "I Don't Want It All"

yeah yeah yeah!

Now I only have to make this fit in my work / family schedule

... so there IS hope more shows will come. Maybe in Austria? OK, just dreaming .... Munich will also do.

Quote from Witchwood

I don't mind the last 50 seconds where it tapers off into that solo.

The preceding three minutes, though, I thought was awful

...wouldn't got that far, but I can't give more than 8 points for a pretty average track.

13 - A strong ballad, which, by coincidence, became the last ever Genesis single (CC99 aside)

It is a good track, I think 12 pts are okay for this.

For me, it lacks a bit power, could be more straight forward and powerful.