Posts by DecomposingMan

    "Rated PG" - That's great!


    "Down to Earth" -- I have this track, purchased as a digital download. This song was one of the few things I liked about WALL-E.


    "Walk Through the Fire" - I have this on the AGAINST ALL ODDS soundtrack. A long time ago I had the single version which, as I recall, was a little different; unlike the album version, it had a creepy voice saying "WALK TWOO DA FI-YA!" at the beginning and at least one other point in the song. I wonder which version will be on "PG."


    "In Your Eyes [* film version from Say Anything - previously unreleased]" - How does this differ from the SO version?

    it is always pleasant but it doesn't go beyond that

    I've thought almost exactly the same thing -- always pleasant but only a handful of songs that really blow me away (and none of them are GEESE tracks, BTW, except maybe "Henry").


    Still, I must like Ant's music, because I have more albums by him than any other artist besides Steve (and one non-Genesis artist)! On the other hand, I've gotten rid of more albums by Ant than any other artist!

    When I first saw (not long after getting into Genesis) that early member Anthony Phillips had made a solo album, I didn't even know what he looked like, much less that he'd already released (by that time) at least 5 other solo albums. (As I recall, I ended up hearing 1984 and BACK TO THE PAVILION before hearing GEESE.)


    GEESE is a very medieval album, and "Wind" fits right in with that. It's not my absolute favorite thing on the album, but it's a nice way to start things off.


    (BTW, for those who haven't heard it, there is an incomplete demo on ARCHIVE COLLECTION VOL. 1 of Ant singing the song himself. A historical curiosity, nothing more.)

    There are five other bands whose output I have fairly complete collections of (including non-album tracks, etc.), at least from certain time periods:


    Chicago (thru 1980)

    The Doobie Brothers (thru 2004)

    The Moody Blues (1967-1973)

    Renaissance (thru 1987)

    Traffic (all periods)


    There's at least a couple there that are unlikely selections for a Genesis fan, but I just "knew what I liked" back in the '70s when my musical tastes were being formed.

    I have all of these albums, but I didn't have definite answers for Feedback, Metamorpheus, Tribute or Sketches.


    On GTR, it's Imagining, and on SQUACKETT it's Tall Ships.

    DEFECTOR: Every Day

    Oops... wrong album!


    BAY OF KINGS: Time Lapse At Milton Keynes

    TLAMK is a bonus track on the CD reissue. Do you have a favorite from the original album?


    BTW, I note that you have picked my least favorites from a few of the albums! Oh well, these things happen.

    What is your favorite song on each Steve Hackett studio album? Here are mine (not including a few where I don't have a definite answer).


    VOYAGE OF THE ACOLYTE: Shadow of the Hierophant

    PLEASE DON'T TOUCH: Narnia

    SPECTRAL MORNINGS: Spectral Mornings (closely followed by Every Day)

    DEFECTOR: Hammer in the Sand (closely followed by The Toast)

    CURED: The Air Conditioned Nightmare

    HIGHLY STRUNG: India Rubber Man

    BAY OF KINGS: Bay of Kings

    TILL WE HAVE FACES: Let Me Count The Ways

    MOMENTUM: Concert for Munich

    GUITAR NOIR: In The Heart of the City

    BLUES WITH A FEELING: Tombstone Roller

    WATCHER OF THE SKIES: GENESIS REVISITED: Déjà Vu

    A MIDSUMMER NIGHT'S DREAM: Celebration

    DARKTOWN: The Golden Age of Steam

    TO WATCH THE STORMS: Rebecca (closely followed by Serpentine Song)

    WILD ORCHIDS: Ego and Id

    OUT OF THE TUNNEL'S MOUTH: Fire on the Moon

    BEYOND THE SHROUDED HORIZON: A Place Called Freedom (in combination with Prairie Angel)

    WOLFLIGHT: Black Thunder (closely followed by Love Song to a Vampyre)

    THE NIGHT SIREN: Anything But Love

    AT THE EDGE OF LIGHT: Under the Eye of the Sun

    Thoughts after my 2nd listen...


    Fallen Walls and Pedestals: Serves a similar function to "Out of the Body," except for being a little less odd. Not bad but doesn't leave much of an impression.


    Beasts in Our Time: Doesn't really light my fire, although there's nothing really wrong with it.


    Under the Eye of the Sun: This is the album's one real "I'm glad I bought this CD" moment for me. Not perfect but a definite highlight. Kind of reminds me of Yes -- or, perhaps, what I would imagine Yes to sound like based on the old Roger Dean album covers.


    Underground Railroad: It seems odd that Steve would revisit the same subject matter as "Black Thunder" so soon, but I like to think of this being as that song's sequel. It loses points for meandering somewhat, but it does have some really good bits. (BTW, I'm going to guess that Durga McBroom is the sister who sings lead at the beginning, since she's the one who has her own Wikipedia page!)


    Those Golden Wings: This is the one song on the album that most rubs me the wrong way. It's not an 11-minute song; it's a 4-minute song padded out with pieces that could be the basis for at least one other song, and which don't flow into each other very well.


    Shadow and Flame: Not much to this one -- just a brief vocal section followed by an extended "Eastern"-sounding jam. Enjoyable for what it is, in sort of a "Rio Connection" or "Howl" sort of way.


    Hungry Years: You know, I've often had the impression that Steve's been trying to learn, not quite successfully, how to write a simple, catchy pop song since 1981. ("Enter the Night" may be the one case where he just about nails it.) He does pretty well with "Hungry Years," though. It calls to mind "Loving Sea" and "Divided Self" (from Squackett), while being better than either. The ending reminds me of "Anything But Love" (probably my favorite post-OOTTM Hackett song).


    Descent: This probably calls to mind different things to different people, but to me it's most reminiscent of "Under the World - Orpheus Looks Back". While Steve does occasionally let a song stay in one groove for a while (see "Shadow and Flame"), this one is especially hypnotic. Not bad.


    Conflict: Like "Fallen Walls", this is pretty good but doesn't leave much of an impression. (BTW, on my Japan copy, at least, it seems the track division between "Descent" and "Conflict" is about 15 seconds too early.)


    Peace: This album's counterpart to "West to East." Had potential to be a decent pop anthem but it's a little too unfocused.

    Sometimes knowing more about a song can just about ruin it for me; sometimes it can really make the song for me. There's one case (not Genesis-related) where learning a song's backstory immediately changed it from one I hated to one that I loved.


    In some cases I just ignore the "official" story behind a song and go with the interpretation that makes sense to me. Cul-De-Sac and Domino are prime examples of where I feel my interpretation fits the lyrics better than the "official" story does. (Hmm, those are both Tony lyrics.)


    As for Happy The Man being about Phil... hmm, I think I might actually like it a little better now.

    Definitely of interest as a Genesis rarity/oddity, but never a favorite song of mine. Some of the lyrics (and, at times, the tone in which they're sung) seem at odds with the cheery, folky music. The guitar melody in the background of the verses doesn't seem to quite fit either.

    Musicians: Tony Banks, Peter Gabriel, Mike Rutherford, Anthony Phillips, John Mayhew

    Um... no.

    In 1971/2 it is said to have been the opening song

    Well, it was the opening song in the 1971 concert heard on the well-known bootleg that's the earliest known live recording by the band. I believe that version of HTM has slightly different lyrics than the studio version.

    After "Underground Railroad" and "Under the Eye of the Sun" I had high hopes for this album, but as it turns out those two tasters are actually its highlights!

    I agree with the above totally.


    I just listened to the album for the first time, and... well, it sounds like WOLFLIGHT and NIGHT SIREN mated and had a baby. Well, "Descent" harks back to METAMORPHEUS somewhat.


    Besides the two "Under" tracks, not a whole lot really grabs me. The best aspect is that Steve seems to have somewhat reined in his tendency to let songs meander all over the place -- with the glaring exception, of course, of "These Golden Wings."


    (BTW, does anyone know who the first lead vocalist on "Railroad" is? There are a couple of ladies listed in the credits, with the same last name, but it doesn't say which one is doing the lead.)


    Steve dismisses the Japan bonus tracks as being throwaways, and I guess I can see why. Still, in their own way they're more fun than a lot of the actual album. Maybe Steve should try just messing around, experimenting and having fun, instead of trying to create a Grand Artistic Statement every time. (BTW, "Teach Yourself Vulcan" is misspelled "Valcan" on both the back cover and the OBI strip.)


    Anyway, maybe I'll feel differently after another listen or two, but as of right now I find it hard to imagine that I would be interested in Steve's future releases. And, as a fan of over 35 years (having all studio albums, except GR2, and quite a collection of miscellaneous stuff), that's a sad thing for me to have to say.

    An impossibility I know, but I now really want to hear The Snake! Something tells me I'd like it.

    Maybe some musically talented type around here could write it!


    In the dream it was implied that the song had a similar concept to "The Serpent," but was by the Genesis of the early '80s.


    I have had many surprisingly detailed dreams about music, usually involving more or less realistic depictions of various recording media. One recurring dream is that I have large numbers of tapes, records and/or CDs stashed away that I have somehow not managed to listen to yet!

    Dreams I can recall having years ago -- back in the days of vinyl -- involved my "discovering" non-existent albums. One involved a fictitious Genesis album, and another involved several fictitious Hackett albums. I can't remember many specifics of the "albums," except that the Genesis one looked kind of like ABACAB and began with a 7-minute song called "The Snake," while one of the Hackett ones had an oddly "retro" cover design, as if from the early '60s or so. Another Hackett "album" looked eerily similar, in its actual vinyl, to TILL WE HAVE FACES -- which, at the time, was still (briefly) in the future!