"Mama" and "Domino" stood out; I think the key changes here really worked and gave them a real 'horror' movie vibe that exploited the darkness of both songs perfectly. "Mama" especially worked with the devilish red lighting and Phil's growling sounding especially menacing.
Of course, "Duchess" really clicked on an emotional level and was played with incredible power and precision. I feel bad for the one show that got "Misunderstanding" in its place. The lyrics, several of which could be related to Phil's current situation, really hit home for me and I think everyone.
Finally, I really loved the acoustic "Follow You, Follow Me." I thought it was so stunning and poignant and felt like it was being sung directly to us. Felt like such a tender moment between audience and band.