Posts by A Whorish Ant

    When he first returned to the stage, I was concerned. His voice wasn't right, he looked uncomfortable and slow getting to and from the stage, and when he had his fall I feared the worst. Well, not the absolute worst, but I thought it might end it before it really got going.


    Since then, his voice has noticeably improved and the few videos I've seen on YouTube from his recent shows he's looked to me like he's moving quite a bit more freely. I don't expect to ever see him behind the kit again, but I wouldn't be surprised if he's performing on his feet again before too long (unless I've missed something).


    I've seen some comments (I think it was on some Facebook groups) that his management should be stopping him from performing, but from what little I know of Phil, I'm pretty sure if he wants to do something (or doesn't), it's his call. There's no chance in hell of anyone booking those US gigs against his wishes. And, unless I'm looking through rose-tinted glasses, if he is improving then long may he continue.

    After having seen Genesis Live 11 times, I have to say that LIVE is the best setting to listen to their timeless and sublime music. It is a shame there are many Genesis songs from their catalog that were never played live: The Brazilian, Wot Gorilla?, Inside Out (not the Hackett Revisited version that is pretty good but is not Genesis), Vancouver and some other lost gems.

    11 times is impressive - I wonder if there should be another thread on how many times people have seen them live? Only two myself.


    They did play The Brazilian live on the IT tour. Did they ever do Just a Job to Do live? Would have liked to have heard that.

    Just saw that one last night! How did you like it? I was fine with it for good entertainment, not familiar though with that whole universe.

    Personally, I loved it. Thought the comedy was very well done, and a necessity from what was otherwise a relentlessly bleak film (for a superhero movie). I know there have been complaints about not giving some characters enough screen time for development, but most have had their own movies for character development, and there's still the second part to this story to come. I don't see how they could have done much better really.

    Thanks, good answer! :)


    Yes, I did mean recorded live. I'm just curious for opinions on ones that people find have that "something" live that, although they may be great in the studio, have that bit of magic in some way. I'll throw in Los Endos too. In That Quiet Earth is a good call.


    I was tempted to add in the reverse, but couldn't think of anything off the top of my head, but I have to say I tend to agree with your choices.

    I'd be interested to know what Genesis songs you feel were significantly better when performed live, compared to the original studio versions.


    Four that spring to mind for me are Afterglow, Abacab, Dreaming While You Sleep, and The Brazilian. Nothing necessarily wrong with the originals, but the live versions have that extra edge in some way.

    I was more immediately impressed with The Force Awakens, but The Last Jedi I feel is more rewarding and the better movie.


    Rewatching the prequels...you're a braver person than I! Phantom Menace is a truly dreadful film. Whilst each follow up improved on the last, I tend to pretend they don't exist. Empire is still my firm favourite, then it's too close to call between SW, ROTJ, TFA, and TLJ. As with my list of Genesis records, the order changes regularly!