I have never liked the covers of Fleetwood Mac & Rumours - I find them pretentiouus & off-putting, and yet they are better than Tusk, which is awful. As for REM, the cover of Automatic For The People is dreadful but so is Out Of Time
If you and I ran a design agency we'd quickly fall out. I like Automatic - it's not brilliant and not in my top 10 but I like it. I'm with you on the cover of OOT, it's terrible. I agree FM and Rumours are bad, but not pretentious as I don't think they were being particularly serious. However, I think Tusk is way better.
I likely posted this cover somewhere else at some point in the last five years, but I really like it. It's the cover of Relatives in Descent by Protomartyr, one of my favorite albums by one of my favorite bands. The woman was an American actress born in the late 19th century, apparently. There's something direct and unsettling about it
I like it a lot and agree with your angle on it