There's never really been an actual Pink Floyd thread here except for this one and even then that's essentially asking who else here doesn't like them. And then of course the one we're in now. I'm mildly amused that the two PF-related threads are "Who else here dislikes them" and "When will Waters shut up". Anyway, I just read this Quietus review of Waters's DSOTM 'redux' and thought I'd link to it in this thread as the review is very focused on RW and its general tone fits well with this thread's subject.
I was only very vaguely aware of this 'redux' and have to say that even if you strip away the reviewer's negativity it sounds worth a miss. He says there's a theremin on the album and that it's one of the best things on it.